Airborne Wind Energy Conversion Systems

Table of contents

 Also known by the acronym AWECS, this is a broad class of technologies designed to harness high-altitude wind power (HAWP), through concepts such as "wind kites" or airborne turbines.  Conventional designs harness wind power using three-bladed, horizontal axis wind turbines, with vertical axis turbines ("wind belts") making up a small remainder.  To convert wind energy into electricity, these designs must convert the horizontal motion of wind into rotational motion via a shaft connected to a generator.  In order to not simply blow away, each model must maintain static force against the wind by some method, necessitating rotors mouted rigidly on towers, close to the ground.  These designs are reliable but are expensive, require large amounts of structural material, are generally confined to collecting energy from winds blowing only in one direction, and do not reach the much stronger winds in the troposphere or stratesphere.  Airborne wind energy systems attempt to overcome these problems.

Saul Griffith of Makani talks about the history of kites, and their potential uses as energy producers today.

Credit: TED: Ideas Worth Spreading

AWES technologies employ a variety of tether and cable designs in order to reach high altitudes, flexibly collect kinetic energy, and once this energy is harnessed, to plug it into an energy distribution grid in the air or on the ground.  First conceptualized in 1833 by John Etzler1 , and then again in 1980 by Miles Loyd2 , high altitude wind power is a more powerful source of energy than surface-level winds.  Most conventional windmills reach into winds about 250 feet from the ground, where wind speed is approximately 16 feet per second.  At around 2,600 feet, wind speed rises to about 23 feet per second, providing potential to generate considerably more energy.3   Winds at altitudes around 32,000 feet have the highest wind power density (a measure of how much wind energy would flow through a wind turbine4 ).  When launched into these altitudes, an airborne wind energy system would be high enough to interact with jet streams flowing more than 10 times faster than surface winds5 , and with much more constancy.  Thus, harnessing the energy from jet streams would provide both more energy, as well as more constant energy, solving the intermittancy issues that surface level wind farms face.

Airborne Wind Energy Systems are a fast-growing technology, with the first HAWP industry conference being held by the Cleanteach Innovation Center of Oroville, CA on November 5th and 6th in 2009.6   Innovative designs have been awarded Excellence in Renewable Energy Awards.7   Google.org, the philanthropic arm of the web-search company, invested $15 million in 2007 in a US based kite company called Makani, as part of its Renewable Energy Cheaper Than Coal program.8

Mechanics and Implementation

Various airborne models exist to convert the horizontal, linear motion of high-altitude wind into the rotational motion needed to drive electrical generators.   Key to most of these designs are complex computer models and control mechanisms designed to maximize the power generated from kites.9   Designs are classified into two categories: aerodynamic and aerostatic.  Aerodynamic designs rely on the wind for support in the air, while aerostatic designs rely on buoyancy to support airborne elements.  Designs can be further classified by ground or airborne generator.  If the generator is located on the ground, then the airborne turbine will not have to support the generator mass or use a conductive tether.  If the generator is aloft, then a conductive tether must be used to transmit energy to the ground.

Flying Windmills

Sky Windpower's uses an aerodynamic, airborne generator design, consisting of a tethered rotor craft.10   The apparatus would initially get into position under its own power by being pushed skywards by motor-powered propellors which would revert to generators once in position.11   The windmill would float instead of fall, since lift generated by wind would overcome the craft's weight, while also generating power.12

Laddermills

The Laddermill is an aerodynamic, ground-based geneartor design concept pioneered by Delft University of Technology in the Netherlands under the leadership of Wubbo Ockels, professor of sustainable engineering and a former astronaut.13   The Laddermill operates by utilizing a number of kite wings connected to a cable, forming a giant loop of ascending and decending kites.  Wind causes upward lift on the wings, as with an airplane wing, and by changing the wing's angle of attack these forces can be either amplified or diminished.14 Wings on one side of the loop are angled to produce maximum lift, while those on the other side are angled to produce only enough lift to support themselves in the air.  The resulting force difference between the two ends of the cable drives the wheel to which the cable is attached.  Connecting this wheel to a generator produces electricity.15   After extensive modelling, the system was successfully tested on Aug. 29, 2007.16

Blimps

Magenn's Air Rotor System (MARS) design is an aerostatic, airborne generator consisting of a helium blimp with with Savonius-style scoops which cause the apparatus to rotate around a horizontal axis.  This generates electrical energy via motors at the attachment-points to its tether.17   This electrical energy is transferred down the 1000-foot tether for immediate use, to a set of batteries for later use, or to the power grid. Helium keeps the device in the air, while its rotation generates the "Magnus effect," providing additional lift and keeping the MARS stabilized within a controlled and restricted location.  This enables it to adhere to Federal Aviation Administration guidelines.18

Balloons

Twind Technology's uses an aerostatic, ground-based generator design involving a tethered, connected pair of balloons with sails attached. The balloons move alternately: one balloon with an open sail uses wind energy to move downwind, drawing the other balloon upwind.  The motion then reverses, with one balloon using a sail and the wind to pull the other. As the balloons move, the tether cable turns the shaft of the ground generator to produce electrical energy or perform other necessary works like pumping or grinding. 

Magenn Air Rotor System

Magenn Air Rotor System

Source: http://gas2.org/2009/08/18/magenn-wi...ine-in-the-sky. Author: Gas 2.0. Permission: Creative Commons Share Alike.

Benefits

There are a number of potential benefits of these technologies, namely: increased energy output, more constant output,

Barriers

Inconsistency

- Electrical Storms

- Even jet streams fail.  Ken Caldeira of the Carnegie Institution’s Department of Global Ecology points out that though " there is enough power in these high altitude winds to power all of modern civilization, at any specific location there are still times when the winds do not blow. Even over the best areas, the wind can be expected to fail about five percent of the time. This means that you either need back-up power, massive amounts of energy storage, or a continental or even global scale electricity grid to assure power availability. So, while high-altitude wind may ultimately prove to be a major energy source, it requires substantial infrastructure.”19

Safety

falling kites/airplanes?(Blimp designs overcome most of these)

Interfering with major bird migratory patterns

This is already a problem with wind farms, although some wind farms are now being outfitted with radar technology designed to anticipate bird flying patterns and shut down wind turbines accordingly.  A new farm, operated by the Spanish firm Iberdrola Renewables, uses radar technology developed by Florida based DeTect, Inc that is able to detect approaching birds up to four miles away, assess their altitude, numbers and visibility, and analyze weather conditions to determine if they are in danger of flying into turbine blades.  If they are, the turbines will  automatically shut down and restart when the birds are a safely away.20   Similar radar detection technology is also being tested for airborne wind energy designs, though it should be noted that certain blimp designs pose a much smaller threat to birds than rotating-blade designs.

Manufacturers

SEE update list:  Stakeholders 

2nd Generation Wind
3Tier
Advanced Rotorcraft Technology
AeroEolica
AEOLICARUS Project
Aeroíx
Airbine
AirborneWindEnergy
AirPlay
Alstom (Switzerland)
Altius Wind Energy
Altaeros Energies
Ampyx Power
Atena Engineering Gmbh
Austin Technology Incubator
Avian Energy
Baseload Energy
CMNA | CMNA Power
CyberKite
Dave Lang & Associates
DESERTEC project
EnergyBird
Energy Potential AB
EnerKite GmbH
Fatronik
Festo
Flight Research Institute (F.R.I.) of Washington
Free Rotor
German Airborne Wind Turbine
Hardensoft International Limited
HeliKites
HeliWind
Heli Wind Power ROTO Project
HighestWind
Honeywell
Isentropic
Joby Energy
KiteEnergy
Kite For Sail, LLC
Kite Gen Research
KITEnrg
Kite Power
KiteBot
KiteGen
KiteLab (Europe)
KiteLab, Ilwaco, WA
KiteLab, Los Angeles, CA
KiteMill
KiteNav
Kitenergy (no double "e")
KiteSailing
KiteShip
KiteTech Energy Systems Limited
KiteTug
KitVes
k Power
Laboratori D'Envol
Laddermill
LEDshift
Magenn Power
Makani Power
Modelway
NTS Energie, Nature Transport System (NTS)
NAWT
Netherlands
OrthoKiteBunch (OKB)
Pavana Dynamics (formerly Red Kite Wind Energy)
Peter Lynn Kites, Ltd.
School of Tethered Flight
Seedwings
Selsam
Sequoia Automation
SkyWind
Sky WindPower
SkyMill Energy (USA)
SkyMill Power (Italy)
Davide Fantinelli
SkyMill.it (Italy)
SkySails
Soaren
SpiralAirFoil, Inc.
SVMtec
Tech Ranch Austin (AWE Biz Incubator)
TEKS
Tethered Airfoil Research and Development group (TARAD
Tethered Airfoils
Tethered Aviation
Tethered Flight
Tethered Flight School
Tethered Flight Technology Consortium
Tethered Turbines
Tethered Wings
Twind®  
USWindlab
Velocity Cubed Technologies
WindLift
WindMapper Pro
WindMueller Aerology Lab
Xerces Blue
ZapKites 
 

Footnotes

1.  The paradise within the reach of all men, without labor, by ..., Volumes 1-2 By John Adolphus Etzler

2. Loyd, Miles L., "Crosswind Kite Power'', Journal of Energy, May - June 1980, Vol. 4 No. 3 pp. 106 - 111.

3. Giant kites to tap power of the high wind by the UK Observer

4. High-altitude winds: The greatest source of concentrated energy on Earth BY CHRISTINE BLACKMAN for the Stanford Report

5. High-altitude winds: The greatest source of concentrated energy on Earth BY CHRISTINE BLACKMAN for the stanford...

6. HAWP conference http://www.hawpconference.org/

7. Excellence in Renewable Energy Awards

8http://www.google.org/projects.html Google.Org projects

9http://www.alternative-energy-news.i...h-giant-kites/

10http://peswiki.com/index.php/Directo...ude_Wind_Power

11http://www.worldchanging.com/archives//004052.html

12http://www.worldchanging.com/archives//004052.html

13http://www.alternative-energy-news.i...h-giant-kites/

14http://peswiki.com/index.php/Directo...d:Ladder_Mills

15http://peswiki.com/index.php/Directo...d:Ladder_Mills

16http://peswiki.com/index.php/Directo...d:Ladder_Mills

17http://www.worldchanging.com/archives//004052.html

18http://www.magenn.com/

19http://www.alternative-energy-news.i...bove-new-york/

20http://www.alternative-energy-news.i...om-wind-farms/

0http://www.wired.com/science/planete.../2005/04/67121

0http://news.stanford.edu/news/2009/j...ds-062309.html

 

Resources

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

You must login to post a comment.